Skip to main content

Base Set 2 vs Base Set: How to Tell Them Apart

Base Set 2 Charizard is 4/130, not 4/102. Raw it's the cheaper card; in PSA 10 it sells for more, because gem copies are far scarcer.

Reviewed & Edited by:Joe from Pallet TownUpdated:Nov 9, 2026

Charizard 4/130 vs 4/102: raw value, PSA 10 and "2nd Edition"

A Base Set 2 Charizard looks almost exactly like the 1999 card: same artwork, same holo, same number 4. It is not the same card, and the market doesn't price it as one: raw, a near-mint Base Set 2 Charizard sells for far less than a near-mint Unlimited Base Set Charizard. Confuse the two and you misprice the card badly, in whichever direction hurts.

Then the slab flips it. In PSA 10, the Base Set 2 Charizard sells for more than an Unlimited Base Set copy, because PSA has handed out far fewer Base Set 2 Charizard 10s: 70, against 488 for the Unlimited original.

We compared the full raw, graded and PSA population ladders for the three cards collectors most often mix up between the two sets (Charizard, Blastoise and Pikachu), plus set-wide prices for 131 priced Base Set 2 editions and 311 priced Base Set editions. The card tiles below show live prices, synced daily.

What Base Set 2 actually is

Base Set 2 is an English-only reprint set released on 24 February 2000. Its 130 cards are reprints drawn from the original Base Set and from Jungle, so most of the famous 1999 artwork reappears, renumbered into one larger list. The 20 holo rares sit at the front of the set, numbered 1/130 to 20/130.

Three things follow from that. First, there was never a 1st Edition print run of Base Set 2 and there is no Shadowless version of it; those distinctions belong to the 1999 Base Set and are explained in our 1st Edition, Shadowless and Unlimited guide. Second, Base Set 2 has essentially one printing per card (131 priced editions across 130 cards in our catalog), so each card page has a single price ladder to read. Third, these are official cards published by Wizards of the Coast, not fakes and not proxies. They just aren't the 1999 cards.

The three checks: number, set symbol, stamp

CheckBase Set (1999)Base Set 2 (2000)
Collector number, bottom rightOut of 102, e.g. 4/102Out of 130, e.g. 4/130
Set symbolNoneSmall symbol below the bottom-right corner of the artwork
1st Edition stampOn 1st Edition copies onlyNever
Shadowless printingYesNo
Cards in the set102130
Released9 January 199924 February 2000

The number is the fastest check, but only the part after the slash. Charizard is number 4 in both sets and Blastoise is number 2 in both, so "4" alone tells you nothing; a denominator of 130 is Base Set 2, full stop. Pikachu is the exception that moves: 58/102 in Base Set, 87/130 in Base Set 2.

The set symbol is your confirmation when the number is worn, hidden by a sleeve or cropped out of a listing photo. If both are missing from the photos, ask the seller for a picture of the bottom-right corner before you pay anything. Our general card identification guide covers the same reads for every other set.

"2nd Edition Charizard" is not a real edition

Search for a "2nd Edition Charizard" and you'll find listings, but no English Pokémon card was ever stamped "2nd Edition". The phrase is a seller's description, not something printed on the card, so it tells you nothing about which card you're looking at. Read the card instead:

  • 4/130 is Base Set 2.
  • 4/102 with no stamp and a drop shadow beside the art is Unlimited Base Set.
  • 4/102 with no stamp and no drop shadow is Shadowless Base Set.

In PSA 9 the Shadowless copy sells for several times the Base Set 2 card, so a vague listing title can hide a large price difference.

Base Set 2 vs Base Set prices, card by card

CardSet and printingPrinted numberRaw, against the other set
CharizardBase Set 24/130Cheaper
CharizardBase Set, Unlimited4/102Pricier
BlastoiseBase Set 22/130Cheaper
BlastoiseBase Set, Unlimited2/102Pricier

Raw, Base Set 2 is consistently the cheaper card, for Charizard and Blastoise alike. A reprint that arrived a year later, without the first set's history, is priced like one. The live prices for all four cards are in the tiles below.

The Base Set 2 Charizard is the most expensive card in its set raw, and its PSA 10 is far scarcer than the original's: 70 on record against 488.

Live price
Charizard #4Base SetUnlimited Holofoil
updated $987.13

The Base Set Charizard page carries every printing, from Unlimited up to 1st Edition Shadowless, so make sure you're reading the row that matches your copy. Our Charizard price guide ranks all of them.

Blastoise shows the same raw pattern at a lower price, and the Base Set 2 copy trades steadily.

Live price
Blastoise #2Base SetUnlimited Holofoil
updated $234.49

The original Blastoise has its own page, with its Unlimited row alongside its other printings.

Why Base Set 2 PSA 10s are quoted higher

The raw discount reverses in the slab on Charizard for one reason: there are far fewer Base Set 2 PSA 10s. PSA has graded 25,061 Base Set 2 Charizards and given 70 of them a 10, a gem rate of 0.3%. For Unlimited Base Set Charizard it's 488 tens out of 106,863, a gem rate of 0.5%. Blastoise tells the same story on scarcity: 61 Base Set 2 tens against 381 for the Unlimited original.

So a Base Set 2 Charizard 10 is both harder to get and scarcer in absolute numbers, which is why its PSA 10 sits so much further above its raw price than the original's does. The population side by side:

CardSetPSA 10s / PSA gradedGem rate
CharizardBase Set 270 / 25,0610.3%
CharizardBase Set, Unlimited488 / 106,8630.5%
BlastoiseBase Set 261 / 12,3220.5%
BlastoiseBase Set, Unlimited381 / 53,0980.7%

That steep top rung does not mean grading a Base Set 2 holo is a good bet. It means the 10 is rare. The realistic outcome sits lower down the ladder: a Base Set 2 Charizard in PSA 9 sells for several times the raw price, but far below the PSA 10. Our raw vs graded guide explains how to weigh the whole ladder rather than the top rung, and what a PSA 10 means covers what the grader is actually checking.

Base Set 2 Pikachu: the card that grades well

The Base Set 2 Pikachu (87/130, a reprint of the Base Set card) is a common, and it is priced like one raw, below an Unlimited Base Set Pikachu. In the slab it's a different story. PSA has graded 3,114 copies and 637 of them are 10s, a gem rate of 20%, far above the holos. Its PSA 10 still sells for many times the raw price; the card page shows the full graded ladder.

Live price
Pikachu #58Base SetUnlimited
updated $8.08

The original Base Set Pikachu has its own page, with each of its printings priced separately.

The whole set: Base Set 2 is the cheaper set to collect

SetPriced editionsPrintings per card
Base Set 2131Essentially one
Base Set, all printings311Several: 1st Edition, Shadowless and Unlimited

Across the board, Base Set 2 is far cheaper: its median card costs a fraction of the median Base Set edition. That comparison flatters Base Set, because its 311 editions include 1st Edition and Shadowless printings while Base Set 2 has one printing per card, but the gap holds all the way down the price list: even the cheapest quarter of Base Set costs more than the cheapest quarter of Base Set 2. If you want the 1999 artwork in a binder for the least money, Base Set 2 is how to get it. For where the real money in the original set sits, see the most valuable Base Set cards.

What to actually do

  1. Read the number after the slash first. /130 is Base Set 2; /102 is Base Set. The number before the slash is the same for Charizard and Blastoise, so it won't help.
  2. Confirm with the set symbol. Base Set 2 has one below the bottom-right corner of the art; Base Set has none.
  3. Price it on its own page. Never use a Base Set comp for a Base Set 2 card, or the other way round; raw, the Base Set 2 Charizard is far cheaper than the Unlimited original.
  4. Ignore "2nd Edition" in a listing title. Ask for the number and a photo of that corner.
  5. Grade a Base Set 2 holo only if it is genuinely clean. The 10 is rare (a gem rate of 0.3% on the Charizard), so judge the decision against the PSA 9 price, not the PSA 10.
  6. Check recent sales on the card page before trading a Base Set 2 slab, and match the grade in each sale title to yours.

We don't sell cards. We publish prices and PSA population counts for both sets, synced daily, so once you've read the number in the corner you can see what your copy is actually worth. Not financial advice - just the numbers.

FAQ

How much is a Base Set 2 Charizard worth?

Raw, a near-mint Base Set 2 Charizard (4/130) sells for far less than an Unlimited Base Set copy. In PSA 9 it sells for several times its raw price, and in PSA 10 far more again: 70 of the 25,061 copies PSA has graded are 10s, which is why the top grade sits so far above the PSA 9. The card page shows the live price at every grade.

What is a 2nd Edition Charizard?

There isn't one. No English Pokémon card carries a "2nd Edition" stamp. A listing that uses the phrase could be describing a Base Set 2 Charizard (4/130) or a Base Set Charizard without the 1st Edition stamp (4/102), so read the number on the card.

How do I know if my card is Base Set or Base Set 2?

Look at the number in the bottom-right corner. Base Set cards are numbered out of 102 and Base Set 2 cards out of 130. Base Set 2 cards also have a small set symbol below the bottom-right corner of the artwork, which Base Set cards don't.

Is Base Set 2 rarer than Base Set?

In graded form, yes: PSA has graded 25,061 Base Set 2 Charizards against 106,863 Unlimited Base Set Charizards, and handed out 70 PSA 10s against 488. Raw, it's the cheaper set: its median card costs a fraction of the median Base Set edition.

Does Base Set 2 have 1st Edition cards?

No. Base Set 2 had no 1st Edition print run, and there is no Shadowless version either. If you see a "1st Edition Base Set 2" listing, treat it as a red flag and check the card against our fake card guide.